Current:Home > ScamsTrump asks judge to throw out conviction in New York "hush money" case -AssetLink
Trump asks judge to throw out conviction in New York "hush money" case
View
Date:2025-04-15 08:30:02
Former President Donald Trump is seeking to have his recent criminal conviction in New York tossed out, and his indictment dismissed, his lawyers said in a filing made public Thursday.
Trump's lawyers say a recent Supreme Court decision on presidential immunity proves they were correct in arguing before the trial that certain evidence and testimony should have been withheld from the jury, because they were related to protected official acts of the presidency.
The Supreme Court found that former presidents have broad immunity for official acts, and barred evidence involving those acts from being used in prosecutions over unofficial activity. Trump was convicted in May of 34 counts of falsification of business records for an effort to cover up reimbursements for a "hush money" payment to an adult film star as he ran for office in 2016.
The reimbursements, to Trump's ex-attorney Michael Cohen, were issued while Trump was president. Cohen said he was the target of a 2018 "pressure campaign" tied to Trump's White House, designed to keep Cohen from cooperating with law enforcement investigating the "hush money" scheme.
Lawyers for Trump said in their filing that much of the testimony and evidence introduced at trial that related to Trump's time in office should not have been allowed, including testimony by former White House communications director Hope Hicks, former director of Oval Office operations Madeleine Westerhout, tweets issued by Trump during his presidency, and Trump's disclosures to the Office Of Government Ethics.
Lawyers who spoke to CBS News recently said Justice Juan Merchan, the judge who presided over Trump's trial, could conclude that while some evidence should not have been shown at trial, it's not enough to set aside the verdict.
The seven-week trial included more than 100 hours of testimony from 22 witnesses, and reams of evidence.
"If there's enough evidence beyond the 'official acts' to sustain the conviction, then it would be what the courts call 'harmless error,'" said Gary Galperin, a Cardozo Law School professor and former Manhattan prosecutor. "No trial is perfect. And the criminal justice system doesn't anticipate or expect perfection."
Trump's lawyers argued in their filing that "presidential immunity errors are never harmless."
"The harmless-error doctrine cannot save the trial result," they wrote. "The Supreme Court's constitutional analysis…forecloses harmless-error analysis."
Prosecutors for Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg's office have until July 24 to file a response to Trump's motion. Merchan has said he will rule on Sept. 6, and if Trump's motion fails, sentencing will take place on Sept. 18.
Trump, who is again running for president, could be sentenced to up to four years in jail, but Merchan has wide leeway and can hand down a fine, probation, or other punishments that don't involve incarceration.
- In:
- Donald Trump
Graham Kates is an investigative reporter covering criminal justice, privacy issues and information security for CBS News Digital. Contact Graham at KatesG@cbsnews.com or grahamkates@protonmail.com
veryGood! (17482)
Related
- 'Malcolm in the Middle’ to return with new episodes featuring Frankie Muniz
- A committee finds a decayed and broken utility pole caused the largest wildfire in Texas history
- U.K. government shares video of first migrant detentions under controversial Rwanda plan, calls it a milestone
- 'Mrs. Doubtfire' child stars reunite 30 years later: 'Still feels like family'
- Connie Chiume, Black Panther Actress, Dead at 72: Lupita Nyong'o and More Pay Tribute
- Facing development and decay, endangered US sites hope national honor can aid revival
- Ohio babysitter charged with murder in death of 3-year-old given fatal dose of Benadryl
- Biden stops in Charlotte during his NC trip to meet families of fallen law enforcement officers
- British swimmer Adam Peaty: There are worms in the food at Paris Olympic Village
- New Bumble feature gives women a different way to 'make the first move'
Ranking
- The FTC says 'gamified' online job scams by WhatsApp and text on the rise. What to know.
- Nurse accused of beating, breaking the leg of blind, non-verbal child in California home
- The Best Mother’s Day Gifts for All the Purrr-Fect Cat Moms Who Are Fur-Ever Loved
- 13 Reasons Why Star Tommy Dorfman Privately Married Partner Elise Months Ago
- Olympic women's basketball bracket: Schedule, results, Team USA's path to gold
- 'Mrs. Doubtfire' child stars reunite 30 years later: 'Still feels like family'
- Facing development and decay, endangered US sites hope national honor can aid revival
- China highway collapse sends cars plunging, leaving at least 48 dead, dozens injured
Recommendation
US appeals court rejects Nasdaq’s diversity rules for company boards
Brad Pitt and Girlfriend Ines De Ramon Make Waves on Rare Beach Date
Proof Chris Hemsworth and Elsa Pataky's Cutest Family Moments Are Always in Fashion
Biden to award the Presidential Medal of Freedom to 19 politicians, activists, athletes and more
Louisiana high court temporarily removes Judge Eboni Johnson Rose from Baton Rouge bench amid probe
Biden Administration Awards Wyoming $30 Million From New ‘Solar for All’ Grant
Gangs in Haiti launch fresh attacks, days after a new prime minister is announced
Gangs in Haiti launch fresh attacks, days after a new prime minister is announced